Comparative Studies 367.02 (call#04417-7)
Fall 1998
Class meetings: 209 Denny, M-W 1:30-3:18. Office
Hours: Mon 11:30-12:30, Wed 11:30-12:30, and by appointment, 485 Mendenhall
Labs. Contact: eglash.1@osu.edu, for phone message call 292-2559 (my phone
is 292-5365, but I am rarely there except for office hours).
Course Description:
This course introduces students to social studies
of science and technology in American culture. We will cover case studies
of public controversies involving science and technology, such as nuclear
power and AIDS, and examine how social groups are able to "appropriate"
technology to empower their own communities. We will also look at the indigenous
technologies that were developed by traditional Native American societies,
at the culture that forms inside professional scientific communities, and
at virtual communities on the internet. This wide variety of perspectives
will enable students to bring the critical traditions of humanities and
social studies to bear on the theory, practice and impact of contemporary
science and technology
Requirements:
Evaluation will be based on the midterm paper (45%),
the final exam (45%), and class participation (10%). You are required
to bring the reading to class so that we can discuss the texts in
detail.
Required Texts:
Course Schedule:
I. Introduction to Science and Technology Studies
9/23 -- Lecture: intro to social studies of science
(Merton, Popper).
II. Public understanding of science and technology
9/28 -- Toumey ch 1, 2, 3
9/30 -- Toumey ch 4,5
10/5 -- Toumey ch 6,7
10/7 -- Toumey ch 8,9,10. Midterm paper first
draft due.
III. Appropriating Technology
10/12 --*Paula Treichler, "How to have a theory in
an epidemic." video: "Doctors, Liars and Women." video: "Seize control
of the FDA."
10/14 -- *Giovanna DiChiro, "Local actions, global
visions: remaking environmental expertise." *DeeDee Hallack, "Watch Out,
Dick Tracy! Popular Video in the Wake of the Exxon Valdez."
III. Science and Technology in Native American
Societies
10/21 -- Video: "Nations Of The Northeast." Handout:
Donald Grinde, "Iroquois Political Theory and the Roots of American Democracy."
10/26 -- *Hermina Poatgieter, Indian Legacy
ch 5,9. *Winona LaDuke: "Voices from White Earth." Midterm paper final
draft due.
10/28 -- *Bruce Smith and M.L. Cornette, "Electronic
smoke signals: native american radio in the US." *Ron Eglash and Turtle
Heart, "Coding, complexity and computation in Native American knowledge
systems."
IV. The mythology of biological determinism
11/2 -- Hubbard ch 4. Video: GATTACA
11/4 -- Hubbard ch 1,2
11/9 -- Hubbard ch 3,5,6
11/11 -- Holiday -- No class
11/16 -- Hubbard ch 7,8,9
11/18 -- Hubbard ch 10,11,12
V. Cyberculture
11/23 -- Turkle ch 1,2
11/25 -- Turkle ch 3,4,5
11/30 --Turkle ch 6,7,8
12/2 --Turkle ch 9,10
Final exam: see master schedule